The Library of Spanking Fiction: Wellred Weekly


Wellred Weekly
Volume 1, Number 10 : August 28, 2012
 
Articles
Items of interest regarding all things spanking

Spanking Labels
by Lea

Following a recent discussion I observed which considered whether spanking should be considered as a part of BDSM or not and, as a consequence, whether tops and bottoms should be classified as sadists and masochists, I started to think about all the labels that we tend to use and specifically those of Top/bottom, dominant/submissive and sadist/masochist. My conclusions which are presented here are all based on my personal views as a mostly discipline-minded bottom and I make no attempt to suggest what might be right or wrong for anyone else. There are, after all, so many different ways that people have their lifestyle work for them and there is certainly no blanket answer to anything.

So, firstly, let's take a look at an excerpt from Wikipedia's entry for BDSM which states:
Activities and relationships within a BDSM context are characterized by the fact that the participants usually take on complementary, but unequal roles, thus the idea of consent of both the partners becomes essential. Typically participants who are active - applying the activity or exercising control over others - are known as tops or dominants. Those participants who are recipients of the activities, or who are controlled by their partners are typically known as bottoms or submissives. Individuals who assume either Top/dominant or bottom/submissive roles - whether from relationship to relationship or within a given relationship - are known as switches.

I don't believe that a person can be simply classified by any of these terms. It may help someone to explain their kink simply be saying that they are a "spanko" but that doesn't really tell the whole story about the person or the specifics of their particular preferences within the overall category of spanking. Even under the spanko umbrella which could in turn be considered itself to be under the BDSM umbrella, there are so many directions one can take. There are many different styles of play, Top/bottom dynamics, and so forth.

I call myself a bottom for lack of a better term - I'm the one on the receiving end of the spanking by that definition. But am I a submissive because I play the bottom role? Not necessarily. I do have some submissive aspects of my personality which are in keeping with the role of bottom. I guess it depends on how one chooses to define 'submissive'. I suppose I could be considered submissive in that I'm letting someone else take control and I submit to the spanking (sometimes more easily than others!). Maybe I'm just reluctant to use the term because of the negative stereotypes that have become associated with it. In other words, if I'm regarded as submissive that means you can do whatever you want to me and I'll just go along with it. And that is certainly not true.

Does being a bottom mean I'm a masochist? I don't think so. It may seem odd that someone who consents to receiving spankings doesn't like pain, but I really don't. Again, this is going to be different for each of us. Some people like playful spankings, and others may like the pain of a really severe spanking. For some it can be a way to relieve stress by letting their pent up emotions out, others may find it erotic. Most of the time my own thoughts and feelings tend to be focussed on the disciplinary aspects of spanking. Things like being scolded and corner time all contribute towards a successful disciplinary spanking. The psychological aspects have an equal or even greater role than the actual spanking itself. If the spanker can actually connect with me and get in my head, that's what really makes it work for me. If I don't have that connection, then the scene isn't going to do much for me. Being in the right frame of mind for it is important and the rituals associated with the spanking can often determine that for me. When I recall the scenes that have really worked for me, I honestly can't recall how hard the actual spanking was in relation to other times that worked less well. That is not the part I remember. What does stand out in my mind though is why I was being spanked and how I was feeling while it was happening.

On the flip side of that, should tops be considered sadists? Well, as a spankee myself I'm not sure I can give an unbiased response to that question as I'm unable to explore that perspective quite so easily. However, I do know what some Tops have told me about their own thoughts and feelings. One person who favors disciplinary spanking said that the most satisfying scenes for him are the ones where he feels he has been able to connect with his partner and for that to happen, it's really more about the emotional and psychological aspects that go along with the spanking, not about how hard he spanks. The spanking itself has to be hard enough to make an impression but it's still only one small piece of the total jigsaw puzzle. I think that viewpoint hits the nail squarely on the head for me. Of course, Tops have as many different variations on what they get out of it as bottoms do but since I'm just not as familiar with that side of things then please feel free to share your opinion.

On the subject of pain within spanking, Margaret Davis at the Spanking Club of New York has written:
"Pain is not as big a part of the punishment as people think. A serious spanking scene - one that makes a submissive feel humble and forgiven - takes carefully crafted mental and verbal skills that pierce their way into the heart and mind of the one who is over your lap.

Serious, intense pain and forceful hitting is not the most important component to a successful spanking. It is the intent, the style and the maturity with which it is delivered and received. A spanking is not an endurance test and no one is keeping score. The experience should be fun and pleasurable."

I don't have all the answers but perhaps the bottom line (pun intended) should be do what you enjoy the way you want to do it, be a safe player, and to hell with the labels.






  Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17